Aardvark Daily
New Zealand's Leading Daily Net-News Online Publication
Publishing Internet News and Commentary since 1995 . InternetNZ, the voice of the New Zealand Internet
If you turn on Java you'll see the LATEST news updates here
Aardvark Weekly | Domainz News | Internet Day | World News | Chat!

award logo

New Sites


You Say
No New Letters

Advertise Here

Previous Articles


Contact Aardvark

Privacy Policy

Dateline: 10 January 2000 Early Edition
Read The Previous Edition

New Zealand Court Loses To The Internet
On Saturday, the NZ Herald published a story, the detail of which (or should I say the suppresion of that detail) has outraged many citzens.

At the heart of the matter is the issue of a suppression order that prohibits the NZ media from publishing the identity of a rich visitor to NZ who was caught importing drugs and let off apparently without even a warning.

Do you want to know who it was?

Then simply harness the power of the Net and find out This story (Link updated 17-Feb-2000, Ed.) gives all the details that the NZ Herald is not able to publish, so why did the court even bother?

Note, earlier links to the story carried by the Associated Press became invalid because the story had "aged off" the servers at the Boston Globe and Yahoo -- that is why the link was updated on 17-Feb-2000.

The court's attempt to hush-up this person's identity is made even more ludicrous by the fact that nobody in New Zealand even remotely cares who he is. The real concern is that he avoided conviction or penalty and managed to have his name suppressed -- yet many other bright young NZers facing the same charges have been whacked with hefty fines, PD or even jail terms, while also having their identities revealed for all to see.

Fortunately for those who are outraged by this situation, it appears that US publishers are not bound by a suppression order made by a New Zealand court and, in this day of instant global communications and online news services, that makes such efforts by the courts to hide someone's identity nothing but a farce.

Even today's Aardvark is probably going to cause some concern to the many local bureaucrats who don't understand the Net -- doubtless some will argue that by merely linking to this US-hosted story, I have violated the suppression order.

Indeed, it is possible that today's Aardvark could revive an issue that has yet to be properly tested in the courts -- how much liability does anyone incur through hypertext linking?

Even the issue of linking to someone else's copyrighted material has yet to be truly examined by the courts in this country.

So will I be hauled up before the court on contempt charges?

I doubt that even the most bumbling prosecutor would attempt such folly. Were I to be prosecuted for such then the courts had better be prepared to take on the entire Internet community -- both at home and abroad. Likewise they'd better be prepared to invest a lot of time and taxpayer money in setting a precedent over the issue of hypertext linking on the Net.

The Net is the nemisis of all those who seek to quarantine information and even the some of the world's most oppressive regimes have failed to control the freedom it offers people -- I think it would be rather presumptuous of the NZ court system to believe it could achieve what so many others have failed to do.

Of course I should also remind the powers that be that Aardvark is actually published in the USA -- not New Zealand, despite the .co.nz domain name.

Clearly the arrival of the Net means that international lawmakers are going to have to spend a lot more time forging reciprocal treaties and creating some kind of consistent respect and enforcement for each other's laws. Or maybe cyberspace should be defined as an entirely new domain -- with it's own set of laws that have no regard for physical borders.

Your comments will be gladly accepted. Just send them to me using the contact form provided and be sure to select whether they are "for publication" or not.


General News & Current Events:
7am.com | NZL News | AUS News | GBR News | World News


Load in new window Clinton Seeks Funds To Fight Cyber-Terrorism Threat
President Clinton is about to ask Congress to foot the bill to fund new systems and technologies to help defend the nation against cyber-terrorists...

Load in new window Domain Name Snafu Leaves 800 Disappointed
A snafu that unintentionally allowed more than 800 potentially problematic .com domain names to be registered has been fixed and disappointed customers have been told their names will be revoked...

Load in new window No ruling in Real, Streambox lawsuit
A U.S. District Court judge decides not to rule on whether to grant RealNetworks a permanent injunction against Streambox, citing a need for more time to examine the case...

Load in new window Teen Magazine clashes with porn site
The publishers of the popular magazine are shocked to discover that the domain name Teenmagazine.com directs users not to "wholesome" content, but to pornography...

Load in new window Y2K Glitch Hits Some Credit Cards
Credit companies are warning consumers that their credit cards might get charged more than once because some merchants failed to update computer software for the year 2000...

Load in new window Sun, MS duke it out over digital home
Don't expect peace under one roof. Both companies have their own -- and very different -- ideas about how your dream house of the future should be built...

Load in new window Microsoft ends Net rebate
Under state loophole customers could spend $400 rebates yet cancel contracts...

Load in new window China registering businesses to monitor Net
Police in China's commercial hub of Shanghai tell corporate Internet users to register in a nationwide drive to increase control over the ...

Load in new window Domain names get with .it
The easy availability of .it domains in Britain could lead to a stampede for expletive-style Web addresses when the service is launched next week...
The Register

More Domainz News

Aardvark Reviews...

Aardvark Daily is a publication of, and is copyright to, Bruce Simpson, all rights reserved
Aardvark's logo created by WebDesign,