Note: This column represents the opinions
of the writer and as such, is not purported as fact
Regular readers will know that I have little time for Michael Gladding
(he also has little time for me after this interview)
and the attitudes of RIANZ when it comes to the "fair use" of music
recordings that customers have paid good money for.
After listening to him stalking on National Radio yesterday morning
I have to say that my opinion of the man and the organisation he heads has
sunk even further.
If you didn't hear the interview then zip over to the Xtra website (try
this direct link to the
streaming media file or this webpage) and
look through the Radio NZ audio archives for the week. It's in part 2
of the 9 to noon programme from Thursday July 8th just after a song by the
Momas and Papas -- about four and a half minutes from the start.
The focus of the interview (which included Judith Tizard MP) was the
proposed change to copyright law that will allow the legitimate purchasers
of copyrighted recordings to perform format shifting -- ie: copy their
CDs onto their computer, MP3 player or whatever.
True to form, Gladding was absolute opposed to the suggestion that format
shifting be made legal, even though he admitted that it was widespread
and that something that he had done himself.
He then explained that the industry had never prosecuted anyone for format-shifting
and it was unlikely they ever would. To emphasize this he trotted out the
cheesy motto "We'll tolerate the exception if you'll tolerate the rule".
"We're not against copying" he said, "we've never had an issue with people shifting
their music say to their IPOD or even to their car."
He added however, that "if this law change is made it threatens our [the NZ recording industry's]
At one point Linda Clark asked "How do you use a CD burner legally?"
Now have your say
Got something to say about today's column, or want to see what
Visit The Forums
While you're here, why not visit the Aardvark
Hall of Shame
and perhaps make your own nomination.
To which Gladding replied "We do realise that this is a technical breach of the law."
Clark also asserted "So you sell a gadget when you know the only way people can use that gadget
is to break the law"
To which Gladding replied: "yes"
So there you have it folks -- Michael Gladding, representing the RIANZ,
is promoting law breaking by his customers in order that they can use
his (as head of Sony NZ) mini-Disc players, CD burners, etc.
This must surely leave any thinking person wondering whether Gladding is a
fit and proper person to be the head of either organisation. Personally,
I find it difficult to give any credibility to someone who openly and
publicly not only admits repeatedly breaking the law, but also encourages
others to do the same.
And if, as we're told by Gladding, it's okay to ignore this part of the copyright
Act, why on earth should we bother observing any other part of it?
Surely, if Mr Gladding and the RIANZ believe that it's okay to format shift then
they must also support changing the law so that such actions are no longer
illegal -- but they don't support such changes and predict all manner of
Gladding claims that "if that happens in New Zealand, the multinational record
companies will flee this country" -- and we're supposed to believe him.
During the course of the interview, Gladding let another little gem of information
out when he said "EMI are about to introduce disks that, whereby when you put it the computer to
make your copy, it comes up with a licensing agreement on the screen."
It looks as if the recording industry is going to try and introduce the
electronic equivalent of a click-through End-user-licensing agreement, such
as that found on most software packages.
Unfortunately for Mr Gladding, a growing number of computer users are either
no longer using MS Windows or have twigged to the fact that holding down the shift key while
inserting a CD will completely bypass such a crude attempt to limit their
freedoms and compromise their rights.
And, if you think the government is on top of this problem in addressing
the issue of format shifting, be aware that the proposed changes still won't give you the
right to backup your legally purchased music CD or make a copy for use in
the car stereo (where the copy-protected original probably doesn't play anyway).
Indeed, Tizard hinted that there may be a clause that expressly forbids CD to
CD copying because -- it's not format shifting.
On numerous occasions during the interview, Gladding rudely talked over the
top of the other two parties in a manner that did his case no good at all.
At the end of it, I came away thinking -- the RIANZ still doesn't have a clue
in respect to dealing with changing technology or treating their customers
like valuable assets rather than criminals.
Go listen to the interview and share your thoughts in the forums.
Yes, You Can Gift Money
I've published this website for the past nine years as a service to the
local internet and IT industry and during all that time it has been 100%
free to access. It is my intention to ensure that it remains completely
free and free of charge and contains only the most sparse levels of advertising.
Aardvark is not a business, it is a free resource.
If you feel that this is a good thing and/or you hold a "geniune affection"
for yours truly -- then you are welcome to gift me some
money using the buttons provided. In gifting this money you accept that no goods,
service or other consideration is offered, provided, accepted or anticipated in return.
Just click on the button to gift whatever you can afford.
NOTE: PayPal bills in US dollars so don't accidentally gift more than
what you were intending :-)
I'm always happy to hear from readers, whether they're delivering brickbats,
bouquets or news tip-offs.
If you'd like to contact me directly, please
this form. If you're happy for me to republish
your comments then please be sure and select For Publication.
Other media organisations seeking more information or republication rights
are also invited to contact me.
Add Aardvark To Your Own Website!
Got a moment? Want a little extra fresh content for your own website or
Just add a
to your pages and you can get
a free summary of Aardvark's daily commentary -- automatically updated
each and every week-day.
Aardvark also makes a summary of this daily column available via XML using
the RSS format. More details can be found
Contact me if you decide to use either of these feeds and
have any problems.
Want to link to this site? Check out Aardvark's
Did you tell someone else about Aardvark today? If not then do it