Google
 

Aardvark Daily

New Zealand's longest-running online daily news and commentary publication, now in its 19th year. The opinion pieces presented here are not purported to be fact but reasonable effort is made to ensure accuracy.

Content copyright © 1995 - 2014 to Bruce Simpson (aka Aardvark), the logo was kindly created for Aardvark Daily by the folks at aardvark.co.uk



Please visit the sponsor!
Please visit the sponsor!

The US recording industry is stealing from ME!

21 February 2012

The recording industry is whining long and hard about how piracy and file-sharing is crippling them.

They're losing billions of dollars every year because people keep "stealing" their intellectual property -- or so they tell us.

As a result, they've convinced various governments around the world to act like a bunch of thugs and introduce incredible penalties for the most modest of crimes.

Well it's about time the recording industry pulled its head in because they're trying to "steal" my intellectual property (and that of thousands of others) and by doing so, they're depriving *me* of revenues.

What a bunch of hypocrites and crooks they've turned out to be!

Here is my own recent experience...

I have been uploading plenty of new videos to my YouTube channels and I'm very careful to ensure that I don't violate anyone's copyright when I do so.

My vids are 100% my own so I should have nothing to fear when I up load them to YouTube -- or so you'd think.

Unfortunately, since YT are now bending over backwards to placate the movie and music industries, the company now taken a step too far.

On three occasions now, I have received emails from YouTube advising me that a content/copyright claim has been made against one of my videos. These claims allege that I have used someone else's content without permission and therefore, the claimant will get any revenues that might arise from advertising that appears on those videos.

How on earth can that happen -- when the videos in question contain no third-party footage, no third party images and no music at all?

Well it's all down to YouTube's automated content-matching system.

In order to catch as many "offenders" as possible, YouTube has obviously significantly loosened the pattern-matching it uses to detect copyrighted material in uploaded videos -- to the extent that it's false-triggering on something as unmelodious as my voice in a "talking head to camera" video.

The last notification of an alleged infringement I received last night didn't even offer a hint as to what music the system thought it had matched. It simply indicated that it contained something which infringed copyright (which it didn't -- here is the video concerned).

Apparently, the content matches some nebulous definition of "music" so the ad revenues will be redirected to a fund that is simply given to some body within the music industry that represents all signed artists.

WTF????

I know the sound of jet engines is music to some people's ears -- but I don't think the recording industry has any right to lay claim to anything in this video -- do you?

Note that this video has been online since October 2008, some three years and four months -- but only triggered the content-match system this week. Clearly, they're really getting vague with their pattern matching now!

Also, if the dull monotone voice you'll find on my RCModelReviews channel now qualifies as "music" (as they've claimed it does) then there can be little hope for that industry -- or maybe I have missed my calling and Sony or EMI should sign me up right away as their newest rapper!

It's pretty obvious that with the absolutely ludicrous way the recording industry has hired the US government to become its mobsters and engage in very shady activities to try and sustain their broken business model, even Google (in the form of YouTube) are shirt-scared that they'll run foul of those "goons with tunes".

In fact, it's got so bad now that if someone like myself doesn't constantly keep an eagle-eye on who is unlawfully claiming the rights to their own intellectual property, they may well end up stealing my money -- by way of fraudulently collecting revenues that do not belong to them.

Surely this is a undeniable case of fraud -- be it automated or not. How can he music industry do this to independent content producers when they themselves keep bitching about how much they're losing to "theft" of their intellectual property?

Other YouTube partners have encountered the same problems recently.

Why is it okay for the recording industry to steal my content but it's not okay for me to steal theirs?

Come on -- I really want an answer to this! Are you listening RIAA -- or are you too busy counting your ill-gotten gains and figuring out whose doors you'll break down tomorrow and whose assets you'll seize as a way of propping up your rapidly decaying business model?

And as a footnote -- it seems that now the music companies are taking pot-shots at each other...

Those who purchase the Sony Vegas video editing software also receive a bundle of "royalty-free" music files which they are entitled to use in their videos without any further payment.

Recently, RumbleFish has been flagging YouTube videos using these tracks as containing copyrighted material belonging to them.

This discussion on the YouTube partner support forums makes interesting reading.

It really does seem that copyright and its enforcement is in need of a major overhaul -- don't you think?

Please visit the sponsor!
Please visit the sponsor!

Have your say on this...

PERMALINK to this column

Oh, and don't forget today's sci/tech news headlines


Rank This Aardvark Page

 

Change Font

Sci-Tech headlines

 


Apart from the kind support of the sponsor, Aardvark Daily is largely a labour of love that involves many hours of hard work each month. If you appreciate the content you find here (or even if you don't) then please visit the sponsor and also feel free to gift me a donation using the button above.

Remember, this is purely a gift, you'll get nothing other than a warm fuzzy feeling in return.


Features:

Beware The Alternative Energy Scammers

The Great "Run Your Car On Water" Scam

 

The Missile Man The Missile Man book

Previous Columns

Kick-me, kick me!
Spring has sprung, the grass is growing, the days are getting longer and warmer. What's not to be happy about?...

Political Friday: And the winner is...
Well here we are - the 2014 general election is now just a day away...

The Dremel hyper-hype 3D printer
Have you heard of Dremel? ...

Pain, I won't stand for it
Normally I'm up at sparrow's fart and sitting at my desk by 6am at the latest...

What defense against surveillance?
Ed Snowden probably surprised nobody with his revelations that all NZers are the subject of mass surveillance last night...

New Zealand, land of the ignorant?
I have to say that I often worry about the future of this nation...

Political Friday (give us all your money)
For many years, the basis of our justice system has been the assumption of innocence -- placing a burden of proof on the state whenever someone is suspected of committing a crime...

You can trust us, we're the police
The courts have agreed that Police should hand over cloned copies of computers and electronic devices that were seized in the armed raids on the Kim Dotcom mansion back in 2012...

iWatch, the end of Apple?
Apple has launched its iWatch...

The truth about Spark's fizzle
As Spark struggled to cope with a problem in its network on Friday it seems that they began grasping at straws...