Google
 

Aardvark Daily

New Zealand's longest-running online daily news and commentary publication, now in its 24th year. The opinion pieces presented here are not purported to be fact but reasonable effort is made to ensure accuracy.

Content copyright © 1995 - 2018 to Bruce Simpson (aka Aardvark), the logo was kindly created for Aardvark Daily by the folks at aardvark.co.uk



Please visit the sponsor!
Please visit the sponsor!

Meccano jumps the shark?

8 November 2018

Who remembers the days of Meccano?

When I was a kid, "making" stuff was all the rage. Some of the most popular gifts around Christmas time were kitsets and things like Meccano which enabled kids to get their hands dirty and actually build stuff.

Taking a store-bought model car out of the box and playing with it until it broke was a pretty transient joy. Building such a toy from a collection of parts and *then* playing with it until it broke was a double joy.

I recall many a long hour spent playing with my own Meccano set back in the day, creating all sorts of ludicrous cranes, vehicles and other structures. I learned a lot about things such as triangulation, planning etc. Not only was it a hell of a lot of fun but it was insanely educational in the way that only "hands on" can be some times.

Believe it or not, Meccano is still a thing.

Sadly, it's not the "thing" I remember.

If you go to the Meccano website you'll see that things have changed a lot since the 1950s and 1960s when I was a keen constructor.

Full marks to the company that now owns the brand for updating to more than just a box filled with strips of green painted steel strips and small fasteners.

Demerits for now making *everything* a purpose-built kitset and effectively removing the very important free-style creativity that the old Meccano fostered.

It seems that these days you buy a specific Meccano kitset (such as this FA-18 Super Hornet -- and that's what you get to build.

What?

My fondest recollections of Meccano involve me sitting in front of a huge wooden box of generic bits and coming up with an idea for a completely new build.

Much of the fun was actually deciding what to build and then designing it -- within the constraints of the components that were to hand.

I seem to recall that any vehicle I was building had to involve no more than three wheels, because one of the wheels from my set was missing. I also recall that my set had no curved pieces so everything had to be created with straight strips and right-angled corner pieces.

Today's Meccano concept, which consists of simply emptying the box onto a table and following the detailed instructions to build a single, solitary design is crap!

Sadly, even though I spent some time searching the Meccano website, I could find no trace of the "Meccano Set" product that so many young lads enjoyed half a century ago.

What a shame!

To be honest, I don't think I'd bother buying any of the Meccano offerings for my grandkids, it's all just too limiting and limited.

Instead, I'd buy them a hot-glue gun, some cardboard boxes, lollipop sticks and an electric motor or two -- then point them at videos like this:

Now that's more like it!

Why has Meccano gone from a product that fostered creativity and inventiveness to one that prevents it? Tragic!

What do readers think? Has Meccano jumped the shark and would we be far better off showing kids how to use the kind of resources shown in that video so they could have a blank canvas and an unlimited ability to exercise their creativity?

Please visit the sponsor!
Please visit the sponsor!

Have your say in the Aardvark Forums.

PERMALINK to this column


Rank This Aardvark Page

 

Change Font

Sci-Tech headlines

 


Features:

Beware The Alternative Energy Scammers

The Great "Run Your Car On Water" Scam

 

Recent Columns

It's that time again!
It's less than six weeks to Christmas...

Seriously, who designed this?
The hot news on the wires this morning is the unexpected and unauthorised temporary routing of Google traffic via China...

NatRad gives up on real news
As I'm sure all regular readers of this column are aware, I am not particularly impressed with the objectivity or performance of today's mainstream media...

Tech giants consolidate their power
Two of the biggest names on the Internet are Amazon and Apple...

Thanks for borrowing our software
An unknown (but seemingly quite large) number of Windows 10 Pro users have had problems over the past 24 hours...

Meccano jumps the shark?
Who remembers the days of Meccano?...

Cores vs clock speed
There's a very real battle going on between Intel and AMD...

It cost how much?
Yesterday I bought a new disk drive...

In 10 years the world will change forever
Nuclear fusion is still just 10 years away...

The strangest thing
I've written a few columns on helium before, because it's a damned interesting element and it is becoming increasingly precious...

More CO2 and methane won't hurt the planet?
I subscribe to a number of email-based newsletters that once interested me but which now simply serve to clutter my inbox...