Aardvark Daily

New Zealand's longest-running online daily news and commentary publication, now in its 24th year. The opinion pieces presented here are not purported to be fact but reasonable effort is made to ensure accuracy.

Content copyright © 1995 - 2018 to Bruce Simpson (aka Aardvark), the logo was kindly created for Aardvark Daily by the folks at

Please visit the sponsor!
Please visit the sponsor!

Why this won't work in New Zealand

26 November 2018

It seems that the urbanisation of population is a problem in most developed countries these days.

People are gravitating towards large cities because that is where the jobs are, and as a result, the infrastructure in those cities is being put under immense pressure. Just ask anyone who needs to use Auckland's motorways at peak times and you'll find proof of that.

So how do you fix this urbanisation problem?

What kind of magic can be used as a method of encouraging people to return to the regional centres where many small towns have actually suffered sorely from population loss or a lack of growth? How can the overwhelming population of large cities be induced to move to smaller towns and cities?

Well in the USA they're trying something innovative. Something that relies on the proliferation of high speed internet.

As this story in the NZH outlines, Tulsa Oklahoma in the USA is trialling a scheme where they're prepared to pay $14,700 to anyone that relocates to a smaller centre and teleworks from there.

De-urbanisation via teleworking is a concept that (as long-time regular readers will be aware) I have long championed. It simply makes sense to take advantage of the Net to get some workers out of the city and allow them to interact via virtual services.

Office space in places like Auckland is ridiculously expensive, as are car-parks and other services. By relocating staff with suitable roles to smaller regional centres, overheads can be slashed dramatically.

I recall my days at 7am News as a great example of this.

At the pinnacle of that company's operations, its headquarters used a grand total of 4 square metres of office space and its workers were distributed around the world, receiving their assignments and delivering their stories via the Net -- and this was in the dial-up days! The monthly overheads associated with the HQ and staff space was measured in mere hundreds of dollars.

Once the venture crapitalists took over, the enterprise was moved to a Symonds Street high-rise, space was set aside for in-house workers and the overheads soared by a factor of 100 or more.

Was the business any more efficient?

Absolutely not.

Was it any more profitable?

No, it went from a healthy annual profit down to a huge loss -- burning over a million dollars before it eventually died through the mismanagement of those venture crapitalists.

There's (once) living proof that teleworking and decentralisation can actually make a hugely positive difference to an organisation's bottom line. Of course it's not a model that suits all businesses but increasingly, as workers become isolated in their cubicals, communicating with other co-workers more via instant messaging and email than by face-to-face, it is a very viable option.

I did once suggest to the fine members of the South Waikato's District Council that they consider setting up a teleworking centre as a way of capitalising on Tokoroa's position as one of the first two towns in NZ to get UFB. Sadly, they weren't interested, mainly because the dinosaur of a mayor at the time had no clue what "teleworking" was. His response to my proposal was "we've already considered having call-centres located here".


So would the US plan work here in New Zealand?

Sadly, I fear not.

Not for any technical reason. Not because I don't think there are plenty of people who'd love to relocate out of the "rat race". Not because I don't think there are masses of young folk whose only chance of getting on the property ladder is to buy outside of a major population centre.

No, it won't work because we have a ridiculous housing crisis that means, for example, that it's almost impossible to rent a house in a regional town like Tokoroa.

I find it hugely ironic that the local council are spending *millions* of dollars, much of which has already been wasted through ignorance and hiring the wrong consultants, to try and attract visitors and their wallets to the town... see this agenda for an extra-ordinary meeting to be held later this week in an attempt to stem the bleeding and bungling.

There's little point in trying to grow a town if you haven't made provision for that growth... or if there simply aren't any houses available to rent.

It's kind of like opening a shop in the high street before you've organised any stock, or cash registers, or shelving, etc. Lunacy of the highest order!

In fact, until NZ gets its housing situation sorted, we (as a country) are significantly restricting our growth and our options. While that's manageable right now, to a degree, I fear for the next five or ten years. Creating huge numbers of affordable houses is not something that can be done overnight -- but population will continue to increase and the demand on housing will ramp up.

Sadly, I fear that by the time we actually realise what a massive burden hour housing crisis has become, it will be far, far too late to remedy it in a reasonable timeframe.

Of course you could always move to Oklahoma and grab $14,700 eh? ;-)

Please visit the sponsor!
Please visit the sponsor!

Have your say in the Aardvark Forums.

PERMALINK to this column

Rank This Aardvark Page


Change Font

Sci-Tech headlines



Beware The Alternative Energy Scammers

The Great "Run Your Car On Water" Scam


Recent Columns

Thanks Warehouse (not!)
In a recent column I lamented the fact that educational and scientific toys seem to be hard to find these days...

The Aussie Government is mental
According to the media, the Australian government look set to pass its law baning unbreakable end-to-end encryption before Christmas...

Magnetic memory, hacks and idiocy
There was nothing that reached out and grabbed me as the subject for today's column so I'm going to just brush over a few items of interest instead...

Buy a book and save the planet?
EBooks are the future and eBooks are environmentally friendly... right?...

The joke that is weather forecasting
I'm getting sick and tired of these cold mornings and rainy days during a time when we ought to be starting to see protracted periods of warmer, drier weather...

Something stinks in Godzone
New Zealand has a housing crisis...

Is the Huawei ban just hypocrisy?
The NZ government has stepped in and told Spark that it can't use Huawei gear to build its 5G cellular network...

New Wifi protocols on the way
Wifi is cool tech...

Another Mars landing
As I type this, there's a window on my screen showing the live scene at the mission control centre for the Insight Mars mission...

Why this won't work in New Zealand
It seems that the urbanisation of population is a problem in most developed countries these days...

Is TradeMe really worth billions?
When TradeMe sold for nearly three quarters of a billion dollars a few years ago, a lot of people (including myself) were surprised...