Aardvark Daily

New Zealand's longest-running online daily news and commentary publication, now in its 25th year. The opinion pieces presented here are not purported to be fact but reasonable effort is made to ensure accuracy.

Content copyright © 1995 - 2019 to Bruce Simpson (aka Aardvark), the logo was kindly created for Aardvark Daily by the folks at

Please visit the sponsor!
Please visit the sponsor!

Justice Minister, meet the internet

12 December 2018

Apparently, Justice Minister Andrew Little is somewhat upset and maybe even a tad surprised that a name suppression order issued by the New Zealand courts has been ignored by the British media.

Whilst such suppression orders carry stiff penalties for NZ media if breached, there is no such penalty available, should the suppressed information be published by someone outside the country. That is exactly what's happened in this case.

The sensitive information is related to the case of English tourist Grace Millane who was sadly murdered a week or so ago.

The name of the accused and other details which were ordered suppressed by the court have since been published by UK newspapers and, since such newspapers are now easily accessible to NZers via the Net, that information is effectively not suppressed at all.

I'm sorry Mr Little, this is just how the internet works.

With a huge percentage of Kiwis now reading online tabloids such as The Daily Mail, "the cat is out of the box", so to speak.

Perhaps it's time for countries to establish a "suppression treaty" or something so that situations like this can be avoided in future.

Given how many other treaties we have so as to ensure consistency and cross-border enforcement of laws, surely such an arrangement is long-overdue in this age of the Net?

Instead of focusing on how better our political overlords can spy on us within a complex legal framework, how about they address the issue of court-ordered suppression in a way that ensures that when one country within the treaty-group orders information to be kept from the public's eye, *all* countries are willing and able to enforce that diktat?

If this is not done then the issuance of such suppression orders is just a joke of the highest order.

How is it fair and just that a Kiwi who might pass on suppressed information for no reason other than "it came up in a conversation" can be heavily fined or thrown in jail for that act -- yet a UK tabloid can openly publish the same info and make money out of it with complete immunity?

Our politicians and lawmakers spent huge amounts of time and sums of money to overhaul our copyright laws so as to account for the arrival of the internet -- how about they do the same for other aspects of our law? Or is it that protecting the profits of rich and influential music and movie publishers and is more important than protecting the concepts of justice?

Either we give up entirely on the concept of suppression orders -- or we get our fingers out and address the glaring hole that is the ability of foreign publishers to ignore those orders and publish with impunity.

What's it to be?

What do readers think and/or suggest?

Please visit the sponsor!
Please visit the sponsor!

Have your say in the Aardvark Forums.

PERMALINK to this column

Rank This Aardvark Page


Change Font

Sci-Tech headlines



Beware The Alternative Energy Scammers

The Great "Run Your Car On Water" Scam


Recent Columns

Oh the irony
YouTube has made a lot of noise about enforcing its community standards of late...

The end of live streaming?
The events of last Friday continue to have deep repercussions on the shape and form that the internet may take from this point forwards...

More internet restrictions
It really does look as if the internet is dying -- from the perspective of being an open, free and somewhat anonymous method of accessing and disseminating information...

The future looks bleak
Today's column was going to be about the tragedy of the Christchurch mosque attacks which happened on Friday of last week...

No longer plane simple
Just about every country in the developed world has now grounded the Boeing 737 Max 8 aircraft, after two crashes that have resulted in the deaths of hundreds of people...

When the sun shines
We all know where clouds live... in the sky...

Actions speak louder than words
I've written a few columns about the (apparent) decline in geekiness and the sad way people seem to be uninterested in the technology that powers the world around us...

A black-box society?
A few days ago I made a video (as you do) about how there seems to be a lack of interest in "making stuff" these days...

Tightening the screws?
The UK is pulling out of the EU in a move that has been called "Brexit"...

Treating symptoms not causes
Governments like to treat symptoms rather than causes...

Money-grab delayed
If you read yesterday's column, you may be interested in what has happened subsequently...