Google
 

Aardvark Daily

New Zealand's longest-running online daily news and commentary publication, now in its 25th year. The opinion pieces presented here are not purported to be fact but reasonable effort is made to ensure accuracy.

Content copyright © 1995 - 2019 to Bruce Simpson (aka Aardvark), the logo was kindly created for Aardvark Daily by the folks at aardvark.co.uk



Please visit the sponsor!
Please visit the sponsor!

Government IT, it's a joke, right?

20 June 2019

Regular readers will recall th at I wrote a column a month or two ago in which I commented on the seemingly outrageous cost for the proposed UK drone registration database.

The Department for Transport in the UK were proposing to create a database that would hold the details of an estimated 170,000 drone owners and this project, the public was told, would cost around 2.8 million quid a year to operate.

Yeah, less than 200K records, accessible via a few web forms and it was going to cost how much?

Well guess what...

As you might have expected, the numbers have been revised -- but not in a good way.

The new price for this database system is... wait for it... 4.1 million quid (that's almost NZD 8 million) to establish and 2.8 million quid a year to operate.

OMG!

In an attempt to justify this horrendous cost for what would appear to be an incredibly simple piece of IT, it has been suggested that things such as the ID verification element may have added to the costs.

That's possible... but here's the kicker...

The UK government (like the NZ government) runs an official online ID system called Gov.uk Verify. Now you'd expect that any other UK database system requiring ID verification would simply defer to that system for such validation.

Um... no.

Instead, the drone database will apparently be using the independent commercial services of credit agencies to perform the verification -- at a significant cost per user.

I believe this is called "having a dog yet barking yourself".

Lunacy!

One can only wonder at the other bumble-footed decisions that have been made and which, as a result, have caused the set-up costs to balloon from the original 2.8m estimate to the latest 4.1m figure.

Of course others have raised the issue of "security" and how it is that creating super-secure systems is far from cheap.

Yes, that may be true... but one would then need to ask how it is that previous governments have been able to set up similar "super secure" systems for an order of magnitude less than the amount now being suggested.

What's more, the UK government already has a myriad of different secure databases for things such as driver licensing, vehicle registration, firearms licensing etc., so why couldn't they simply adapt these by adding a few extra columns to the schema and creating variants of the online forms used for data-entry/queries/reporting?

How on earth, regardless of the security level, anyone can come up with a setup cost of 4.1 million for a database containing less than 200K records with probably no more than a couple of dozen fields beggars belief.

But then again... when "public servants" are spending other people's money, the sky is the limit. After all, Tokoroa is getting five new toilets for $4m in an attempt to lure passing travelers into the CBD where (it is hoped) they might decide, on the spur of the moment - as they're pulling up their trousers, to buy a fridge, washing machine and lawnmower.

Sigh!

Please visit the sponsor!
Please visit the sponsor!

Have your say in the Aardvark Forums.

PERMALINK to this column


Rank This Aardvark Page

 

Change Font

Sci-Tech headlines

 


Features:

The EZ Battery Reconditioning scam

Beware The Alternative Energy Scammers

The Great "Run Your Car On Water" Scam

 

Recent Columns

The hysteria takes its toll
It's less than six weeks to Christmas but there is one gift that won't be as popular this year as it has been in years-past...

Something strange is happening on Mars
Everyone loves a good mystery...

Talking of weather
If you ever need to strike up a conversation with someone but have no shared interests then the subject of weather is often a good place to start...

The dependency trap
No, this isn't a column about the evils of welfare handouts...

Google/YouTube have done it again
Hands up everyone who remembers Google+, aka G+...

Social media disasters
Yesterday I wrote about my disappointing experiences with Noel Leeming's online chat and price-match service...

Noel Leeming, could do better!
I've spent a few grand with Noel Leeming (NL) in recent years...

Oh the irony
Last night was Guy Fawkes night here in Godzone...

Busting Scammers
I love debunking and busting scams. It's one of the best games on the internet...

The curse of immortality
I'm starting this week with a thought experiment that has significant ethical and moral implications...

Mayor Jenny Shattock
Regular readers will know that I've had more than a few altercations and disagreements with the local South Waikato District Council...