Google
 

Aardvark Daily

New Zealand's longest-running online daily news and commentary publication, now in its 25th year. The opinion pieces presented here are not purported to be fact but reasonable effort is made to ensure accuracy.

Content copyright © 1995 - 2019 to Bruce Simpson (aka Aardvark), the logo was kindly created for Aardvark Daily by the folks at aardvark.co.uk



Please visit the sponsor!
Please visit the sponsor!

Picking winners(??) again

29 July 2020

The New Zealand government has an appalling record when it comes to picking winners in the sci-tech fields.

I have honestly lost count of the number of columns I've written berating the government for throwing money away on ridiculous concepts and startups that it was clear, right from day one, were never going to become viable businesses.

The most recent of these was the Martin Jetpack and I was a strong critic right from day one. Never the less, a million or so taxpayer dollars was squandered on this "one man's folly" of an idea that eventually crashed and burned, as predicted.

Way back at the start of the year another of these tech initiatives was announced and I also challenged the sensibility and economic viability of what was being claimed for it.

On the 20th of January I wrote a column titled Will this fly? in which I expressed concern that significant sums of public money were about to be thrown at Dawn Aerospace in the Waitaki District of NZ.

My "spidey-senses" were set a tingling by the "test flight" of their new "unmanned rocket propelled space plane" -- which appeared to actually be little more than a store-bought jet-powered RC model aircraft with a tiny rocket motor added to the tail.

I suggested that this was a very poor candidate for public money and that the concept of "flying" a payload to the upper reaches of the atmosphere was hardly a new or innovative concept. If it was such a great idea, why wasn't it already in regular use?

Well the MBIE obviously didn't agree because they threw a big fist-full of taxpayers' money at the company and now I see they've just dumped another pile-o-spin on the media.

According to this story, Dawn Aerospace has unveiled its "Mk-II Aurora" unmanned space plane.

Or did they?

Excuse me?

All I see is another RC model. For some reason the NZH didn't include the "supplied" pictures of the new craft but TechCrunch did.

Now let's be *very* clear, the model you see in those pictures is not something that will be fulfilling the promise made by Dawn to its investors. To be honest, I could have built the very same thing (likely for a lot less money) using off-the-shelf parts.

A fancy piece of fibreglass does not a space-vehicle make.

In fact, fancy pieces of fibreglass are a dime a dozen. Anyone remember this?.

Yep, we all know how the Snark, a "revolutionary" new piece of aerospace kit from former MP Trevor Rogers turned out (clue: Mr Rogers ended up in jail.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not for one minute suggesting that Dawn Aerospace is anything but a legitimate attempt to create a new "unmanned space plane" service, however I do think the commercial viability of their plans are a little "questionable".

Sure, NZ has had some wonderful success in this area in the form of RocketLab but I can't help get the feeling that Dawn's ability to raise funding may have come more from riding on the shoulders of those giants than on the actual practical merits of this "space plane" concept.

Certainly if I was the MBIE or a private investor, I'd be looking for something a lot more tangible than a large RC model with a roman candle on the tail as an indicator of the company's technical prowess and their ability to fulfill the stated objectives.

I sure hope I'm going to be proven wrong on this one but only time will tell. Let's do a little retrospective in a few year's time when Dawn Aerospace will either have become a thriving service provider -- or when it does a Martin Aerospace-like dive into receivership.

Place your bets ladies and gentlemen!

Please visit the sponsor!
Please visit the sponsor!

Have your say in the Aardvark Forums.

PERMALINK to this column


Rank This Aardvark Page

 

Change Font

Sci-Tech headlines

 


Features:

The EZ Battery Reconditioning scam

Beware The Alternative Energy Scammers

The Great "Run Your Car On Water" Scam

 

Recent Columns

Google needs dismantling
Google was a great idea and a great company, many years ago...

The best job is...
When I was a kid, most of my peers wanted to be firemen, policemen builders or plumbers...

The big backfire?
The world is headed for economic turmoil...

The rest of your life
Like most teenagers, I gave very little thought as to what I'd be doing half a century down the line...

Where are we headed?
As the world lurches from crisis to crisis, catastrophe to calamity and plunges head-long into an abyss of uncertainty, one can only wonder what will happen next...

Most satisfying
Over the decades I have designed, built and commissioned many bits of bespoke technology...

Politicians, some are nasty
With the NZ economy tanking to the tune of a 12 percent contraction, the last thing I wanted to hear yesterday were the words of National Leader Judith Collins...

Spark, what are you thinking?
Spark has stated in the media that it has a goal of getting up to 40 per cent of its broadband customers on to wireless technology by 2023...

The sky is falling again
What a terrible place the world has become...

The current "Big Thing"
Every now and then, a "big thing" comes along...

Python versus BASIC
Prepare your inner geek...