Aardvark Daily aardvark (ard'-vark) a controversial animal with a long probing nose used for sniffing out the facts and stimulating thought and discussion.

NZ's leading source of Net-Industry news and commentary since 1995
Australasia's "New Economy" News And Commentary Site
Today's Headlines | Contact | New Sites | Press Bin | Job Centre | News Search
Online Forums -- Friend or Foe? 31 August 2000 Edition
Previous Edition

Readers Say
No Comments Yet
Have Your Say
At 2:15 pm yesterday, NZ's media became free to print the name of the US millionaire who, earlier this year, faced drug charges in an Auckland court.

After the 4 NZ Herald primed readers in Tuesday's online edition and again in yesterday's morning edition, the very few people who still interested in this morsel of information were probably waiting for 2:15 pm to roll around with bated breath.

Although it was probably just a tiny point of law, that 2:15 pm time is probably quite important -- insomuch as publication of the name prior to that precise moment would, I believe, have been a technical breach of the suppression order. That's why the disclosure wasn't in yesterday's print edition right?

And, sure enough, at 2:15 pm, the NZ Herald published 4  this story containing the previously suppressed name.

However -- the NZ Herald's website had already, unwittingly, been carrying this information since 1:16 pm -- apparently in breach of the still active suppression order.

How could this happen? Why would a responsible publisher seemingly operate in breach of a suppression order?

Well the answer is simple -- they likely didn't know they were doing it. That's because the name had been published by some member of the public calling themselves "Nude Boy" who posted the information to the NZ Herald website's discussion forums.

4  This screenshot shows the posting that visitors could read yesterday -- note the time it was posted.

As an online publisher who has, on several occasions, used online forums as a method of encouraging debate and increasing traffic levels, I'm very much aware of the risks involved.

If such forums are fully automated (as are the NZ Herald's) then the publisher would appear to be protected from prosecution if they are abused by some delinquent user -- so long as any postings which are offensive, defamatory or breach the intellectual property rights of others are removed as soon as they're detected.

I'm not sure however that this protection would apply to the breach of a court order covering name suppression -- perhaps a reader with the necessary legal qualifications would care to comment?

There can be no doubt that, if you have enough vocal readers who act responsibly then online forums are a real boon to your site. However, it only takes one idiot to ruin such a facility for everyone. What's worse -- if your site has little traffic to start with then your forums can become mute testimony to that fact.

Having had the forums on my own site repeatedly hijacked by a small group of idiots, I've opted for a moderated feedback system that sees me approve (although I do not edit) each piece of feedback before it is published. While this definitely slows down discussion, it is the most effective way to guarantee the quality and relevance of such contributions.

Forums -- Friend or Foe? The answer is that they can be both. Tread carefully!

From Yesterday
There was a very positive response to the prospect of Aardvark Weekly being revived in PDF format -- it seems that Aardvark readers spend a lot of time at their conveniences and paper still rules in the toilet!

Several offers to supply a copy of Adobe Acrobat were also forthcoming and I'll get back to those making the kind offers today -- then it's full steam ahead.

Another common request was that Aardvark be made available in a format suitable for the Palm Pilot (also allowing "convenience" browsing) and as a result I am currently preparing an AvantGo channel that will be announced shortly.

Also, after yesterday's request, I did receive a few emails from people working on entrepreneurial projects despite the current climate of gloom and I'll be doing a feature on some of them in an upcoming issue. It's not too late to have your efforts included though, so tell me about them.

And, don't forget that tomorrow is "Lighten Up" day -- so if you've come across any little humorous gems on the Net, please let me know now so they can be shared with Aardvark's readers.

As always, your feedback is welcomed.

Security Alerts
Trojan horse rears its head on Palms (CNet)

PGP Email Security Flaw Fixed (AP)

Glitch leaves IM contact lists vulnerable (CNet)

Input Validation Problem In rpc.statd (CERT)

Experts corroborate Windows, IE security hole (CNet)

Virus Alerts
'Pokey' virus hits U.S. (CNN)

New strain of "Love" virus steals passwords (CNet)

ILOVEYOU Virus Rides Again - As A Resume  (NewsBytes)

Bookmark This Page Now!

Sites In Trouble


NZL Sites
NZ Netguide
NZ Herald Tech
PC World NZ

AUS Sites
Fairfax IT
Australian IT
AFR Tech
AUS Netguide
NineMSN Tech
APC Magazine
Corporate IT

USA Sites
CNNfn Tech
Yahoo Tech
ZDNet Tech
USA Today Tech
7am.com SciTech

UK Sites
The Register
BBC SciTech


The Day's Top News
4 = open in new window
New Zealand

4  US energy giant buys NZ software
An American energy retailer has bought customer management software from Auckland-based Peace Software to help it face the deregulated US power market...

4  NZ Web site goes Dutch
Broadband Internet company Chello is to mount a special set of Web pages relating to the "Nieuw Zeland Going Dutch" exhibition at Te Papa in Wellington, and to related matters on the theme of Dutch immigration to New Zealand...


4  Certain messages allegedly can freeze Nokia phones
A Norwegian mobile Internet company asserted today that some Nokia mobile phones may freeze temporarily if certain text messages are sent to them...

4  WAP or I-Mode: Which Is Better?
It's been one of the most contentious debates on the wireless Internet: What is the best way to access the Internet on your phone, WAP or i-mode?...

4  Analysts question big brands' jump to Net
Attention Kmart investors: Traditional retailers who venture online face massive financial losses and a skeptical stock market...

4  FTC Reports Spike In Identity Theft Complaints
Identity theft complaints have tripled in the last six months and have averaged more than 1,000 calls a week in July, the Federal Trade Commission said Wednesday...

4  Judge Rejects MP3.com Claim Universal Wants It Dead
A judge on Wednesday rejected an accusation by MP3.com Inc. that Seagram Co.'s Universal Music Group was using its copyright infringement claim to put the online music company out of business...

4  Too Hard to Read?
OK, we may be getting older, but we're also going blind reading copy on most web sites...


4  Pair looking smart
WITH shares of LookSmart rising on the back of an equity alliance with Telstra, husband and wife founders Evan Thornley and Tracey Ellery have filed to cash in $US6.7 million worth of shares in their company...
Australian IT

4  BMCMedia reports a $6.8m loss
Internet advertising company BMCMedia.com yesterday announced a net loss, in line with analysts' forecasts, of $6.87m for the six months to June 30...

4  Alston pushes for an end to cybersquatters
This week the Federal Government will table legislation to back its view that domain names ending in .au should belong to Australians...

4  $4 billion for Telstra
Data and Internet services have propelled the telco to a huge profit for the year ending June 30, up 16% from the previous year...


4  The new virus war zone: Your PDA
Personal digital assistants and smart phones are increasingly connected to the Internet -- but also a potential world of hurt from viruses...

4  The Truth Is in There ... They're Sure of It
The federal government hoped that posting once-classified UFO-related papers on the Web would satisfy conspiracy theorists. Boy, was it wrong...
LA Times

4  E-Stamp Trials Internet Postage in Europe
Internet postage pioneer E-Stamp Corporation announced Wednesday the introduction of its service to Europe with a trial in the Netherlands...
Internet News

4  Sony launches much-anticipated Palm device
Sony and Palm last night unveiled the Clie, the first fruit of their previously announced alliance and the Japanese electronics giant's much-anticipated entry into the handheld computing market...

Looking For More News or Information?

Try the Aardvark News Search page or look here.co.nz

Copyright © 2000, Bruce Simpson, free republication rights available on request