Note: This column represents the opinions
of the writer and as such, is not purported as fact|
Most readers will be aware that some time ago now, several new top level domains
(TLDs) were activated to augment the existing generics: .com, .net and .org
Perhaps the most sought-after of these new TLDs was .biz which is intended
to supplement .com as a TLD for businesses on the Net.
Naturally there was a bit of a gold-rush when the .biz TLD was opened up
and as a result there have been a number of disputes over who is entitled
to certain names.
One of those names whose allocation was contested turns out to be NewZealand.biz.
Check Out The Aardvark PC-Based Digital
Entertainment Centre Project
It seems that in the initial rush to secure .biz names, NewZealand.biz
was scooped up by iSMER,
apparently a UK-based individual or group.
Not surprising really, since quite a few country names in the .com, .net
and .org namespace have been taken by individuals or groups which have
no specific entitlement.
for example, held by Virtual
Countries Inc and
is held by USA.net Inc.
So why am I writing about the ownership of NewZealand.biz today?
Well it seems that The NZ Government have successfully seized this name
from its formerly legal registrant by claiming they own the trademark
Well that's not strictly true -- the government claims that it *applied*
to trademark the term "New Zealand" in June of last year and
is still undergoing examination.
I also notice that the records show that a "Warning Of Abandonment" notice
was sent on July 4th in respect to this application.
In its infinite wisdom, WIPO appear to have
upheld the government's claim
and has ordered that the name be transferred to the NZ Government.
Should we be worried by this?
Well I think so.
Perhaps the registrants of NewZealand.com, NewZealand.net, NewZealand.co.nz
and all the other permutations not currently held by the NZ government are
now going to come under scrutiny. Will they also have their paid-up
and previously legal entitlements usurped?
Late Update: it looks as if someone
(the NZ Government?) *is*
challenging for NewZealand.com.
And just what's going on with that trademark?
Trademarks are supposed to be specific to a narrow set of products or services,
how can the government trademark the name New Zealand across the entire spectrum
of all the many and varied products and services that could be represented
on the Net?
And why was a notice of abandonment sent in respect to their application?
Is it simply coincidence that the trademark application in question was made
on the eve of the launch of the .biz TLD? Will the government, having
used that application to wrestle control of NewZealand.biz from its original
registrant, now allow the application to lapse - it having served its purpose?
Something smells here.
Note clause 3.g in the Procedural History in
the WIPO Ruling:
(g) By e-mail of August 10, 2002, Complainant requested to the Center
that "the decision in this matter, when it issues, not be published", and
indicated that Respondent had agreed to this request. By e-mail of
August†10,†2002, Respondent "confirm[ed] our consent that the decision in
this matter, when it issues, not be published"
Why the call for secrecy? (and who goofed on this one?)
I certainly wouldn't want to see NewZealand.biz being used for any site
that might wish to unfairly capitalise on New Zealand's reputation -- but
I also think that using bully-boy tactics and skulduggery to trick/convince
WIPO to hand over someone else's property is a somewhat dastardly deed.
Should we feel pleased that our government is protecting our reputation in
cyberspace? Or should we feel ashamed of the tactics it's adopting to do so?
Will the government go after newzealand.biz.com as well? Or have they already
sent in the cyber-SIS to scuttle
that site ahead of time?
Where will it all end? -- and should Danny de Hek be worried about the domain
If you want to have your say on the contents
of today's column then please do so.
Only comments marked "For Publication" will (if I have time) be published in the
readers' comments section.
Add Aardvark To Your Own Website!
Got a moment? Want a little extra fresh content for your own website or
Just add a
to your pages and you can get
a free summary of Aardvark's daily commentary -- automatically updated
each and every week-day.
Aardvark also makes a summary of this daily column available via XML using
the RSS format. More details can be found
Contact me if you decide to use either of these feeds and
have any problems.
Want to link to this site? Check out Aardvark's
Did you tell someone else about Aardvark today? If not then do it