Aardvark Daily aardvark (ard'-vark) a controversial animal with a long probing nose used for sniffing out the facts and stimulating thought and discussion.

NZ's leading source of Net-Industry news and commentary since 1995
PAYBACK TIME! | Headlines | XML feed | Contact | New Sites | Archives | Forums | About
Note: This column represents the opinions of the writer and as such, is not purported as fact
USA Makes A Dog's Breakfast Of Spam Law 27 November 2003 Edition
Previous Edition | Archives

Please support the sponsor
Sponsor's Message
It was a good idea really -- pass a law that would make spam illegal and by doing so, help to ease the burden of hundreds of millions of Net users whose mailboxes are regularly filled with solicitations for penis enlargement products and cheap loans.

Unfortunately, as is so often the case, it appears that US politicians either didn't really understand the problem or were simply swayed by lobbyists with big fat wallets.

The result -- a law which, according to some analysts, actually legitimises spam and makes the sending of such dross less likely to land the spammer in hot water because, being issued by the federal government, it over-rides the tougher legislation some states have already passed.

Let's take a quick look at where the US legislators went wrong and hope that our own government -- if it ever gets around to dealing with the problem, can learn from those mistakes.

The Aardvark PC-Based Digital
Entertainment Centre Project

Yes, at last, this feature has been updated again! (31 Mar 2003)

Firstly, this is basically an opt-out law. That means spammers can send you email (subject to a few basic caveats) so long as they offer you the right to opt-out of future mailings.

Unfortunately, opting out of a spam sent to promote one company won't mean you're opted out of other spams sent to promote other companies or even different products sold by the same company.

So, if there are 1,001 companies selling herbal viagra, you'll have to opt out 1,001 times. If those 1,001 companies actually sell 10 different products then you're already up to 10,010 opt-outs required!

Readers Say

Got something to say about today's column, or want to see what others think?  Visit The Forums

Have Your Say

But wait, it gets worse!

Since the opt-out process is not clearly defined by the law, there's no reason why a spammer can't direct you to their website to opt-out.

Now think of the money to be made if you set up a page with a thousand and one porno-banners -- you know, the type that pay affiliates a few cents per impression or click-through. The opt-out process could earn a savvy spammer hundreds, or even thousands of dollars in commissions!

Suddenly a new business model is born -- people spamming stuff that they know nobody will buy -- simply so they'll opt out and, at the same time, view enough ads to nicely fill up the spammer's bank account.

Let's see -- send out a million emails, expect 100,000 opt-outs. Each opt-out visitor to the website generates 10 ad-banner impressions at $0.05 each --- hey, that's a cool $50,000 per spam-run! Sure beats flogging herbal viagra right?

Another part of the law seeks to make it easier for us to cope with spam and requires all spam to have some kind of identifier in the subject line so that it can be more easily filtered out by those who don't want to receive it.

Yes, this is a laudable suggestion (although not so laudable as introducing measures that might mean unwanted spams are never sent in the first place) but there's no strict definition of how such emails should be identified.

The most sensible would be to use a tag such as [ADV] or [SPAM] in the subject -- however, since there's nothing defined, spammers could use almost anything and claim it was an indicator that the message was spam. Hell, a lot of the spam I get now is already identifiable to humans because it contains a series of random characters in the subject line -- but try to get a computer to recongise that as a spam marker and you'll be wasting a lot of CPU time.

Another seemingly sensible clause is the one that prohibits spidering websites to collect email addresses -- but how are you going to enforce this?

There's just no way to prove that a spammer got your email address from spidering a website.

Even if you set up a webpage with addresses that are only ever used on that page -- there's still no guarantee that some hapless websurfer hasn't mentioned that address to others as part of a conversation on a mailing list somewhere.

No, I'm sorry but the US legislators have simply proven that they're totally incompetent when it comes to dealing with spam. Maybe our ITC Minister was right when he implied that politicians simply aren't smart enough to deal with the problem of spam.

However, speaking of spam solutions, David Harris (of Pegasus Mail) was kind enough to respond to a previous column I wrote on the issue of spam. I invite you to read his comments.

If any Aardvark readers want to share an opinion on today's column or add something, you're invited to chip in and have your say in The Aardvark Forums or, if you prefer, you can contact me directly.

Yes, You Can Donate
Although the very kind folks at iHug continue to generously sponsor the publication of Aardvark, the bills still exceed the income by a fairly significant amount. It is with this in mind therefore that I'm once again soliciting donations from anyone who feels they're getting some value from this daily column and news index. I've gone the PayPal way of accepting donations because the time involved in processing a bunch of little credit-card billings sometimes exceeds the monetary value they represent. Just click on the button to donate whatever you can afford. NOTE: PayPal bills in US dollars so don't accidentally donate twice what you were intending :-)

Contacting Aardvark
The Best of Aardvark Daily I'm always happy to hear from readers, whether they're delivering brickbats, bouquets or news tip-offs. If you'd like to contact me directly, please this form. If you're happy for me to republish your comments then please be sure and select For Publication.

Other media organisations seeking more information or republication rights are also invited to contact me.

Add Aardvark To Your Own Website!
Got a moment? Want a little extra fresh content for your own website or page?

Just add a couple of lines of JavaScript to your pages and you can get a free summary of Aardvark's daily commentary -- automatically updated each and every week-day.

Aardvark also makes a summary of this daily column available via XML using the RSS format. More details can be found here.

Contact me if you decide to use either of these feeds and have any problems.

Linking Policy
Want to link to this site? Check out Aardvark's Linking Policy.

Did you tell someone else about Aardvark today? If not then do it now!

Security Alerts
Mail server flaw opens Exchange to spam
(CNet - 17/11/2003)

Trojan Horse Bedevils Explorer Users (NewsFactor - 6/10/2003)

CERT Issues Warning for OpenSSH Flaw (AtNY - 17/09/2003)

fix for DB2 Linux security flaw (CNet - 17/09/2003)

Virus Alerts
New virus disguised as PayPal e-mail (CNet - 17/11/2003)

New Virus Dresses Up as E-Mail (Wired - 03/11/2003)

New worm poses DoS attack threat (CNet - 03/11/2003)

Sober Windows virus spreads (BBC - 29/10/2003)

Bookmark This Page Now!


GeekZone (NZL)
SlashDot (USA)


NZL Sites
NZ Netguide
NZ Herald Tech
PC World NZ
NZOOM Technology WordWorx

AUS Sites
The Age
Australian IT
AUS Netguide
NineMSN Tech
IT News

USA Sites
CNNfn Tech
Yahoo Tech
ZDNet Tech
USA Today Tech
7am.com SciTech

UK Sites
The Register
BBC SciTech


My Jet Engines
Check Out Me And My Jet Engines

Today's Top News Stories

Open in New Window = open in new window
New Zealand

Open in New Window Peering problems persist
TelstraClear is rejecting suggestions that it ever offered free peering to Auckland-based ISP ICONZ, saying the companies had a commercial agreement that including "traffic exchange."...


Open in New Window Scripting flaws pose severe risk for IE users
A set of five unpatched scripting vulnerabilities in Internet Explorer creates a mechanism for hackers to compromise targeted PCs...
The Register

Open in New Window Lawmakers: Spam Bill Is a Turkey
Not a single United States senator voted against the anti-spam bill wending its way toward the White House...
Internet News

Open in New Window Phoenix toughens up BIOS
The software that sits between the OS and a PC's hardware hasn't changed much in decades. Phoenix Technologies wants to introduce greater security and copy protection...

Open in New Window E-commerce targeted by blackmailers
Companies trading online are under attack from gangs who blackmail with denial-of-service attacks...

Open in New Window Cable failure hits UK Internet traffic
A fault in an undersea cable system linking Europe and the US has disrupted Internet and transatlantic telephone services across Britain...

Open in New Window MPAA, RIAA seek permanent antitrust exemption
Just weeks after an antitrust suit was filed against the RIAA by webcasters, the music labels' lobby group, is, along with Hollywood, seeking a permanent exemption...
The Register


Open in New Window Govt website provides safe surfing guidelines
The Federal Department of Information Technology, Communication and the Arts has provided information on safe surfing and protecting children from offensive material online...
The Age

Open in New Window Thousands of Telstra mobile customers hit by outage
Thousands of Telstra mobile customers across parts of NSW and the ACT were without services last night after a software failure caused a major outage...
The Age

Open in New Window Vodafone to go it alone on 3G
VODAFONE Australia has announced it will commence planning for the initial deployment of a third generation (3G) network in Australia as a Vodafone only initiative, with the launch still targeted for 2005...
Australian IT


Open in New Window Been Gazumped by Google?
Starting on the 16th of November, a major shift in results was seen on Google. Veterans recognised that Google appeared to be doing a major update...

Open in New Window Microsoft gears up for carmakers
A slimmed-down Windows CE will power a variety of in-car electronics, such as navigation and music devices...

Open in New Window Toddler wounded in Segway hit-and-run
A three-year-old San Francisco girl has become the first pedestrian to know what it feels like "when Segways attack."...
The Register

Open in New Window Game console sales start to slip
Sales of game consoles such as the Playstation 2, Xbox and GameCube are starting to slow down...

Looking For More News or Information?

Search WWW Search Aardvark

Privacy Policy | Copyright © 2003, Bruce Simpson, republication rights available on request

jet engine page