Aardvark Daily

New Zealand's longest-running online daily news and commentary publication, now in its 19th year. The opinion pieces presented here are not purported to be fact but reasonable effort is made to ensure accuracy.

Content copyright © 1995 - 2015 to Bruce Simpson (aka Aardvark), the logo was kindly created for Aardvark Daily by the folks at

Please visit the sponsor!
Please visit the sponsor!

The law sells-out to big money

16 February 2012

Helicopters, armed police, asset seizures without proof of guilt and imprisonment before conviction without bail -- those are the seemingly unjust actions of the NZ government in respect to Kim Dotcom and his alleged copyright infringing activities.

Now you might think that's pretty severe but it's starting to look as if it's just the tip of a very nasty iceberg.

This morning we awoke to find that UK police are now engaging in similarly draconian actions in respect to copyright infringement.

Remember -- we're not talking about a violent assault. We're not talking about rape, murder or even armed robbery. We're talking about people moving bits and bytes of data around the Net using their computers, phones and tablets.

Yet, despite the relatively low (in most people's minds) severity of the crime, the actions and penalties being talked about are unbelievably severe.

In the case of the latest infringement policing in the UK, the RnBXclusive music sharing site has been shut down by police and an arrest made.

Fair enough you might think.

But wait... there's more...

Instead of charging the operator of the site with copyright offenses, the site's operator has been arrested on suspicion of conspiracy to defraud.

WTF? Remember that the only reason the FBI was able to recruit the NZ police to act on their behalf when arresting Kim Dotcom and raiding his house was because they included racketeering and money-laundering charges amongst their allegations.

It seems that police and prosecutors are playing dirty, very dirty indeed.

It also leaves me wondering if there's any point in having copyright laws -- if prosecutions are going to be made on the grounds of far more serious offenses, even when the alleged offender has simply operated a file-sharing site.

Those who used the RnBXclusive website to swap files should also be worried.

It seems that a "scare campaign" is now being kicked-off, with a view to dissuading users from daring even visit such sites.

In respect to this case, the UK's Serious Organised Crime Agency (SOCA) has stated "those who downloaded them [music files] could face up to 10 years in jail and an unlimited fine".

Stop the bus!

Ten years jail and an unlimited fine -- for unlawfully downloading a copyrighted music file?

Compare this to the penalty for shoplifting a CD.

Compare this to the penalty for committing an armed robbery to steal a CD -- or indeed, an entire truck-load of CDs.

This is sheer and utter lunacy and must be stopped.

It is now patently obvious that the recording and movie industries are spending inordinate amounts of money to "buy" strategic power within the legal system.

Need more proof?

Well here's what SOCA said about the nature of the "crime" of filesharing:

"As a result of illegal downloads, young, emerging artists may have had their careers damaged. If you have illegally downloaded music, you will have damaged the future of the music industry."

If that isn't a line direct from the PR department of the music industry I don't know what is.

Now I'm dead against any form of copyright infringement -- but I'm even more against this blatant abuse of the legal system by a bunch of rich corporations with the money to buy whatever favours they desire.

When things get so bad that the penalties for simply downloading a file exceed those for committing a robbery, committing a violent assault or even committing manslaughter -- something is wrong, very, very wrong.

I also find it rather hypocritical that the recording industry are pleading for the rights of their members when we regularly see stories like this one in the media.

Let's be honest, the recording industry cares only about their own self-interest.

Please visit the sponsor!
Please visit the sponsor!

Have your say on this...

PERMALINK to this column

Oh, and don't forget today's sci/tech news headlines

Rank This Aardvark Page


Change Font

Sci-Tech headlines


Apart from the kind support of the sponsor, Aardvark Daily is largely a labour of love that involves many hours of hard work each month. If you appreciate the content you find here (or even if you don't) then please visit the sponsor and also feel free to gift me a donation using the button above.

Remember, this is purely a gift, you'll get nothing other than a warm fuzzy feeling in return.


Beware The Alternative Energy Scammers

The Great "Run Your Car On Water" Scam


The Missile Man The Missile Man book

Previous Columns

It's 1998 all over again
Aardvark readers are smarter than average and also tend to take a greater interest in politics and current affairs...

Is there a new online battle looming?
Most people appreciate that advertising is just a fact of life on the Net these days...

All Yr Wndwz 7 R bLnG 2 ME!!!
The folk at Microsoft probably signed a collective "oh dear" (actually, it was probably a lot less family-friendly than that) this morning...

Volkswagen scandal kills the diesel option?
I have always had trouble reconciling the claims that noisy, smelly, smoky diesel engines are somehow less polluting than their comparatively quiet, odourless, visually clean petrol equivalent...

Martians are probably slimy
Interesting news on the space front -- NASA is now convinced that they have spotted liquid water (or signs thereof) on the surface of Mars...

EVs for government?
There is increasing pressure for the government to start using EVs in its massive fleet of vehicles...

The lithium battery problem worsens
Lithium is a highly reactive element and its affinity to combine with other elements, releasing energy along the way, has made it a very effective component of modern lightweight, high power-density batteries...

Pay attention, it's important!
One of the biggest news stories this week was the way that a US drug company purchased the rights for a particular treatment and then jacked up the price by 5,000%...

Can we fix it?
Over the past few weeks I've been tossing around a lot of ideas for creating new, engaging, educational, entertaining YouTube content and here's another...

Silent Spring (the tech version)
One of the most important books ever published is Silent Spring written in 1962 by author Rachel Carson but today's column isn't about the birds and bees of which she wrote...

Maker by proxy?
Just nine days until I start rolling out some exciting new content for my XJet YouTube channel and I'm still searching for good ideas...